The main difference between optical isomerism and geometric isomerism is that optical isomerism is due to the presence of a chiral center and leads to mirror-image enantiomers with distinct interactions with polarized light, whereas geometrical isomerism arises from restricted rotation around a bond and results in different spatial arrangements of substituents.
Optical isomerism and geometric isomerism are two forms of isomerism commonly observed in organic chemistry. Understanding these forms of isomerism is vital for understanding the diverse structures and properties of organic compounds.
Key Areas Covered
1. What is Optical Isomerism
– Definition, Spatial Arrangement, Properties
2. What is Geometrical Isomerism
– Definition, Spatial Arrangement, Properties
3. Similarities Between Optical Isomerism and Geometrical Isomerism
– Outline of Common Features
4. Difference Between Optical Isomerism and Geometrical Isomerism
– Comparison of Key Differences
Key Terms
Cis-Trans Isomerism, E-Z Isomerism, Enantiomerism, Optical Isomerism, Geometrical Isomerism
What is Optical Isomerism
Optical isomerism, or enantiomerism, arises from the different spatial arrangements of atoms within a molecule. Optical isomerism occurs when two molecules are non-superimposable mirror images of each other, similar to our hands. These mirror-image molecules are called enantiomers. Enantiomers have the same chemical formula and connectivity of atoms but differ in their spatial arrangement, which leads to distinct physical and chemical properties. The presence of a chiral center in a molecule is a prerequisite for optical isomerism. A chiral center is an atom, typically carbon, bonded to four different substituents. The asymmetric arrangement of these substituents around the chiral center creates two mirror-image isomers. The simplest example is a carbon atom bonded to four different groups, denoted as R and S, according to the Cahn-Ingold-Prelog priority rules.
Figure 1: Optical Isomerism
Enantiomers possess identical physical properties such as boiling point, melting point, and solubility. However, they exhibit different interactions with polarized light. This property is known as optical activity. One enantiomer rotates the plane of polarized light clockwise (dextrorotatory or +), while the other rotates it counterclockwise (levorotatory or -). The magnitude of rotation is quantified using a specific unit called specific rotation.
The phenomenon of optical activity arises due to the interaction between the enantiomer and the plane-polarized light waves. When plane-polarized light passes through a solution of one enantiomer, it is rotated either to the right (clockwise) or left (counterclockwise). The direction and extent of rotation depend on the nature and concentration of the enantiomer, as well as the wavelength of the light.
What is Geometrical Isomerism
Geometric isomerism, or cis-trans isomerism or E-Z isomerism, is a type of stereoisomerism that arises from the different spatial arrangements of atoms or groups around a double bond or within a cyclic structure. Geometric isomerism occurs when there is restricted rotation around a bond, leading to different spatial arrangements of substituents. The most common examples of geometric isomerism are observed in molecules with a carbon-carbon double bond (alkenes) or in cyclic compounds, such as cycloalkanes or coordination complexes.
The two main types of geometric isomers are cis and trans isomers. Cis isomers refer to the arrangement where substituent groups are on the same side of the molecule, while trans isomers have substituents on opposite sides. In more complex structures, the terms E (entgegen) and Z (zusammen) are used to describe the arrangement of substituents based on their priority according to the Cahn-Ingold-Prelog (CIP) system.
The presence of a double bond or a cyclic structure with restricted rotation prevents the interconversion of cis and trans isomers without breaking the bond. This restricted rotation gives rise to differences in physical properties, such as boiling point, melting point, density, and solubility, as well as chemical reactivity.
Figure 2: Geometric Isomerism
Applications of Geometric Isomerism
Geometric isomerism has significant implications in pharmacology, agrochemicals, materials science, and coordination chemistry. In pharmacology, it affects the biological activity and metabolism of drugs, while in agrochemicals, it influences the toxicity and effectiveness of pesticides. In materials science, geometric isomerism impacts the properties of functional materials like liquid crystals, and in coordination chemistry, it affects the spatial arrangement and properties of coordination complexes.
Similarities Between Optical Isomerism and Geometric Isomerism
- Optical isomerism and geometric isomerism are forms of stereoisomerism, which means that the isomers have the same molecular formula and connectivity of atoms but differ in their spatial arrangement.
- Both optical isomerism and geometric isomerism can influence the physical and chemical properties of molecules.
- They contribute to the field of stereochemistry, which focuses on the three-dimensional arrangement of atoms and the study of their spatial relationships.
Difference Between Optical Isomerism and Geometrical Isomerism
Definition
Optical isomerism is the property of a molecule to exist as mirror-image isomers due to the presence of a chiral center, whereas geometric isomerism is the phenomenon where different spatial arrangements of substituents occur around a bond or within a cyclic structure, resulting in distinct isomeric forms.
Spatial Arrangement
In optical isomerism, the isomers are non-superimposable mirror images of each other, and they have the same connectivity of atoms but differ in their three-dimensional arrangement. On the other hand, geometric isomerism involves different spatial arrangements of atoms or groups around a double bond or within a cyclic structure. The arrangement of substituents may be cis (same side) or trans (opposite sides) or have a specific configuration based on the priority rules in the Cahn-Ingold-Prelog system (E-Z nomenclature).
Symmetry
Optical isomers are optically active and exhibit no internal plane of symmetry. They cannot be superimposed on their mirror images. But geometric isomers can have internal planes of symmetry. In cis isomers, the substituents may be symmetrically arranged on one side of the molecule, whereas trans isomers lack internal symmetry.
Isomer Interconversion
Optical isomers can be interconverted by breaking and reforming chemical bonds or through physical processes such as crystallization or racemization (involving an intermediate mixture of both enantiomers). However, geometric isomers cannot be interconverted without breaking the covalent bonds around the double bond or cyclic structure. The rotation around the bond is restricted, making interconversion more challenging.
Properties
Optical isomers have identical physical properties, such as boiling point, melting point, and solubility. They exhibit different interactions with polarized light. However, geometric isomers may have different physical properties, including boiling point, melting point, density, and solubility, due to their distinct spatial arrangements.
Applications
Optical isomerism is particularly relevant in pharmacology, where enantiomers of drugs can exhibit different biological activities, metabolism, and interactions with biological targets. Separation and analysis of enantiomers are crucial for ensuring the safety and efficacy of pharmaceutical compounds. Geometric isomerism, on the other hand, has implications in various areas, such as organic synthesis, materials science, and coordination chemistry.
Conclusion
The main difference between optical and geometric isomerism is that optical isomerism is due to the presence of a chiral center and leads to mirror-image enantiomers with distinct interactions with polarized light, whereas geometrical isomerism arises from restricted rotation around a bond and results in different spatial arrangements of substituents.
Reference:
1. “Optical Isomerism – Definition, Condition, Examples, Occurrence.” Byju’s.
2. “Explain geometrical isomerism.”Byju’s.
Image Courtesy:
1. “Milchsäure Enantiomerenpaar” By NEUROtiker – Own work (Public Domain) via Commons Wikimedia
2. “Cis and trans 1 methyl 4 hydroxymethyl cyclohexane” By MarkForeman – Chemdraw drawing (CC BY-SA 3.0) via Commons Wikimedia
Leave a Reply